Gartner predicts most IT-led social media initiatives will fail

Posted by Vikki Chowney
on 3rd February 2010

mossOn the back of Forrester’s latest update to its Technographic ladder, Gartner is hot on the analyst company’s heels this week with a study about business use of social media.

Playing on the advice that an integrated approach is the way forward, Gartner suggests that IT departments will struggle to successfully deploy social media until they develop a more “calculated approach”. In fact, the findings show that a massive 70% of IT-led social media initiatives within a business will fail, and that the majority of IT teams will struggle to make the switch from traditional technology platforms such as email, web conferencing and instant messaging, to implementing community-based communications systems like microblogs.

The scale of the issue is such that Gartner also predicts that social networking will replace email completely for one in five businesses across the world by 2012. Its suggestion is that organisations that allow business departments to lead the way in terms of social media, rather than IT, will have a significantly higher success rate of around 50%.

Though taking responsibility and deciding who’s going to lead the charge is important, it’s also vital that internal teams work together to ensure that any social media activity is kept consistent, relevant and useful for all of those involved. If teams can’t sort out internal communications together, anything externally is doomed from the beginning.

Recent comments
  • Excellent update--not surprising, because it mimics the same kind of failure that occurred when organizations were forced to absorb IT-led intranet installations (as in: "We were thinking about an intranet." "Good, we've just designed one for you." Function has never followed form in organizational communication, and is unlikely to do so because its intent may be "social". If IT and the C-Suite decide to be militant about maintaining control in this area, the damage could be profound and long-lasting.
  • Great point! The Economist this week is devoting a whole special report to social networking, and touches on the impact of social networking on business. It argues "...that social-networking technologies are creating considerable benefits for the businesses that embrace them, whatever their size."
    The special report does not do a deep dive into how companies are benefiting, just a few hints here and there. They mention Enterprise 2.0, which is the IT/software manifestation of social media in a business context. Where they fall short, and what your article points out - is that for social media strategy in corporations to be successful, it needs to go beyond social technology/software, hence beyond the IT department, and must include new leadership styles, organization structures and culture. I wrote a post expanding on this point here: http://bit.ly/8qh8DY
blog comments powered by Disqus